剧情介绍
《无声的呐喊》/原名:《》上映日期:2000-10-25,
暂无
If you could make your deaf child hear, would you? Academy Award-nominated Sound and Fury follows the intimate, heart-rending tale of the Artinians, an extended family with deaf and hearing members across three generations. Together they confront a technological device that can help the deaf to hear but may also threaten deaf culture - and their bonds with each other. For Peter Artinian and his wife, both of whom are deaf, a surgical ear implant for their five-year-old daughter Heather means a choice between two worlds - an unfamiliar hearing world and the deaf world, a robust culture in its own right united by a uniquely visual and artistic language. Heather Artinian - precocious, vivacious, and avidly curious about implant surgery - is caught between her deaf parents and her hearing grandparents, as they argue passionately about her future. The debate is sometimes silent, but by no means quiet. When all is done, Sound and Fury speaks volumes about the choices we make and the battles we fight in order to be heard..《无声的呐喊》百度云网盘资源以及《无声的呐喊》高清mp4迅雷下载,《无声的呐喊》BT下载,希望您能喜欢!
这几日突然被disability studies灌了一脑,确实是作为健全人很少会想到或者学到的东西,建议配合相关理论书观察思考……
只是因为大多数人类生来都能听到声音,就将生来就听不到声音归为一种残疾。如果颠倒过来的话,能听到声音的还是“正常人”吗?
纪录片做到这样真的很棒了
英语作业+++1
无所谓对错的争论中处处都闪耀着人性的光芒
Such an eye-opener.
Mark 几度激动哭
以前从来没有考虑过这个问题
一出生就是听不见任何声音的大概无所谓。可是父母不是聋哑人的肯定希望自己孩子是可以听见的啊。下雨的声音,鸟叫的声音,风吹过树叶,歌声,乐器,哪怕是噪音,都希望自己的孩子是可以听见的。况且你不能要求每个人都学手语,选择不装人工耳蜗的话某种程度意义上来说你能交流的社会圈子就小了很多
不错
在教授Marsha(这部电影的Sound editor) 的课上看到了这一部很棒的纪录片。两点想说的: 1. 感觉美国人的观念真的很像那些片中助听器支持者对待deaf culture 的态度 2. 从片中的双方观点让我也想到了关于科技更迭的一些正反观点。 科技不断向前,感谢电影记录了这更迭里的人性光辉
来自聋人的愤怒。医疗科技,主流文化,身体经验与身份认同。Heather在九岁的时候接受了耳蜗移植手术。
聋哑人对于自身的缺陷并没有抱有很多遗憾和不甘心,更多的反而是自豪和幸福,甚至在他们眼中deafness根本不是一种缺憾。即便这种自豪与幸福在我们看来多半是来自于他们对世界有限的认知,即他们并未体验过有声音的世界,但也许比起同情,尊重永远是更恰当的。
Great documentary. Real eye opener.
The film was funded by Cochlear Inc.--what sort of balanced narrative or objective POV could you possibly expect?
at 大钟新村apartment, recommended by Gene, 如果没有这部纪录片,我根本不知道deaf people是怎么想的,以及他们所形成的文化deaf culture是什么样的。到底是谁给了这些人压力?他们的母亲说他的成长frustrated,但究竟是谁觉得frustrated?是deaf自己还是抚养的人?是谁给了这个压力?
Quotes: The implant is simply invasion. It doesent seems right for a deaf person. Because as a deaf, the nature is being in a deaf world.
Deaf Community在片子里被表现的太闭塞了,可能是新科技时代起步的文化冲击吧,但是大小家庭为下一代的未来做抉择精神好感人...
或许真如祖母说的,或许多年以后,deaf culture也会成为历史。
影评 http://www.douban.com/review/1344582/